Take off Career

The Tenure Debate: Safeguarding Academic Freedom or Stifling Innovation?

The Importance and Purpose of Academic Tenure

Academic tenure is a concept that has been around for over a century, providing job security to professors in higher education institutions. It has been a subject of debate over the years, with some arguing that it stifles innovation while others contend that it supports academic freedom.

This article will explore the importance and criticisms of academic tenure.

Defending Academic Freedom

One of the primary purposes of academic tenure is to defend academic freedom. This means that professors are able to freely teach and research controversial and sensitive topics without fear of reprisal from their institutions or external actors.

The ability to speak out and challenge the status quo is one of the hallmarks of academic progress. Without tenure, professors may face pressure to tone down their research or teaching in order to placate students, donors, or administrators.

Controversial subjects such as feminism, racial justice, and political ideology are often areas that are targeted by detractors, making tenure a necessary protection for both faculty and students. Tenure provides a critical safeguard against censorship and promotes academic inquiry, allowing lecturers to explore new ideas and inspire their students to do the same.

Detractors and Criticisms of Tenure

Critics have taken aim at the tenure concept, arguing that it is outdated and in need of an overhaul, if not outright abolition. They point to perceived flaws in the current system, including instances of academic misconduct and lack of accountability.

Critics suggest that the tenure system is too rigid, making it difficult for institutions to weed out incompetent or abusive faculty members. Similarly, some detractors argue that the tenure system is untenable in today’s academic environment, which is increasingly focused on the bottom line.

Institutions are steering towards relying on non-tenure track instructors and adjuncts to fill teaching positions, which are less costly and offer no job security. Critics have argued that this shift has been detrimental to the quality of education students receive as tenure-track faculty members have traditionally taken a leadership role in shaping the curriculum.

Rising Reliance on Adjuncts and Non-Tenure Track Instructors

With the increasing reliance on adjuncts and non-tenure-track instructors, tenure is becoming less common in higher education institutions. Many experts believe that this shift is bad for both faculty and students.

Non-tenure-track positions offer little job security, low pay, and little support from the institution, making the experience of teaching and researching increasingly precarious. This precariousness is alarming since teaching and research jobs are some of the most important for the development of new ideas and innovations.

The loss of talented faculty members who leave academia due to a lack of job security should worry us because it is not only a step away from academic freedom, but also from progress for students.

Importance of Tenured Faculty for Higher Education

The importance of tenured faculty members cannot be overstated. They are the backbone of higher education institutions, providing the expertise and leadership necessary to shape the curriculum and mentor the next generation of scholars.

Without them, higher education institutions would struggle to maintain the level of excellence they have achieved. Tenured faculty have many roles, including researching, writing scholarly articles and books, providing service to their departments, and teaching courses.

The job requires a high level of dedication, expertise, and consistency that is difficult to achieve without the job security offered by tenure.


Academic tenure is a complex and nuanced subject that has been widely debated and discussed. It remains an important part of the higher education system, protecting the rights of professors to research and teach controversial subjects without fear of censorship or backlash.

Detractors argue that the system is outdated and fraught with issues, including the loss of job security for faculty members and the shift towards non-tenure-track positions, which can harm the quality of education. While the debate over academic tenure continues, one thing is clear: tenured faculty plays an essential role in higher education.

They are tasked with a wide range of responsibilities and play a key role in shaping the direction of both their institutions and their fields. Ultimately, any conversation about academic tenure must consider the importance of job security, academic freedom, and the quality of education received by students.

Top Ten Massachusetts Institutions with Strong Tenure Foothold

For both institution and faculty member, tenure is an essential part of the academic system. Ultimately the goal is to have a strong partnership between employer and employee.

In Massachusetts, there are several institutions where this partnership has been successful, resulting in a high percentage of tenured faculty members. Here, we explore ten of these established institutions.

Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT)

MIT is one of the most well-known and respected educational institutions in the world, with the majority of its faculty members being tenured. It has a faculty of over 1,000 members and a tenure rate of over 90%.

The university has a reputation for encouraging research, innovation, and interdisciplinary learning opportunities, resulting in a vibrant intellectual culture within the MIT community.

Roxbury Community College

Roxbury Community College is an educational institution committed to providing a transformative experience for its students. The college has a tenure rate of 95%, making it one of the highest in the state.

The institution is known for its support of first-generation college students, ensuring that tuition and fees remain affordable, and for its commitment to diversity, equity, and inclusion. New England Law | Boston

New England Law | Boston is a private and independent law school located on Stuart Street in Boston, Massachusetts.

It has a tenure rate of 80%, which ensures that its faculty members remain committed to quality teaching and scholarship. The school encourages social justice and public service, and its faculty is composed of expert practitioners from diverse backgrounds.

Cape Cod Community College

Cape Cod Community College is a two-year college that serves students on Cape Cod, offering associate degrees in several fields. Its tenure rate is over 80%, providing job security for faculty members while also supporting the colleges commitment to providing high-quality academic opportunities for the community.

Holyoke Community College

Holyoke Community College is a public community college located in Holyoke, Massachusetts. It has a tenure rate of over 70%, and its faculty is committed to ensuring that students receive valuable transfer opportunities to four-year colleges, as well as hands-on training in vocational and technical fields.

The college has a commitment to social justice, and its faculty is made up of experts from diverse backgrounds.

Massachusetts College of Art and Design

Massachusetts College of Art and Design is a public college in Boston that offers undergraduate and graduate degrees in creative arts. It has a tenure rate of over 60%, providing its faculty members with job security and the opportunity to contribute to the vibrant culture of artistic expression in the city.

Salem State University

Salem State University is a public university located in Salem, Massachusetts. It offers undergraduate and graduate programs in a wide range of disciplines.

Its faculty tenure rate is over 50%, providing job security for faculty members while ensuring that students receive top-notch education from committed educators.

Middlesex Community College

Middlesex Community College is a public community college located near Lowell, Massachusetts. It offers transfer programs, vocational and technical training, and community education opportunities.

Its tenured faculty rate is over 50%, providing job security while also ensuring that students receive high-quality instruction from committed educators.

Wheaton College

Wheaton College is a private college in Norton, Massachusetts. It offers undergraduate programs in liberal arts and sciences, as well as graduate programs in education and psychology.

Its faculty is composed of experts in their fields and is committed to providing top-notch education to its students. Over 40% of the faculty members are tenured, ensuring that they are able to make a long-term commitment to the institution.

Mount Wachusett Community College

Mount Wachusett Community College is a public community college located in Gardner, Massachusetts. It offers vocational, technical, and transfer programs, as well as community education opportunities.

Its tenured faculty rate is over 40%, providing job security and ensuring that the institution is committed to quality teaching and research.

Methodology for Determining Tenure Foothold

Determining the tenure rate of educational institutions requires data collection and analysis. The data utilized in this article comes from the Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS) database maintained by the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES).

The IPEDS compiles data annually from educational institutions across the United States, with the aim of promoting the accuracy, quality and timeliness of educational data. The tenure rate was calculated as the percentage of faculty members with tenure status out of the total number of instructional faculty members.

The calculation of faculty with tenure status includes full-time and part-time professors on the tenure track, as well as those already tenured. Faculty not on the tenure track were excluded from the calculation.


Faculty tenure is essential to the academic system as it ensures job security, academic freedom, and institutional support for research, teaching, and scholarship. In Massachusetts, there are ten higher educational institutions with high faculty tenure rates, providing job security and quality teaching.

Data collection and analysis from the Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS) database were utilized in calculating tenure rates, providing an accurate portrayal of tenure status in Massachusetts educational institutions. Honorable Mention: Episcopal Divinity School

Episcopal Divinity School (EDS) was a theological institution located in Cambridge, Massachusetts that trained students for ordained Episcopal ministry, as well as for social justice and community organizing.

The school had a commitment to diversity, inclusion, and progressive theology.

Closure and Affiliation Changes

However, in response to the changing role of religious institutions in the modern world, EDS suspended its degree programs in 2017. The Cambridge campus no longer functions as a school, having sold to Lesley University in 2019.

The academic affiliation of EDS was transferred to the Union Theological Seminary in New York City in 2018.

Commitment to Social Justice and Tenured Faculty Rate

Though EDS is closed, its legacy remains relevant to discussions about higher education. With a 100% tenured faculty rate, EDS was committed to supporting academic freedom and maintaining job security for its faculty.

The institution supported social justice and progressive theology through its coursework and practical ministry programs. However, EDS struggled to sustain its mission and faced financial constraints which culminated in the decision to close.

Despite that, the institutions faculty developed an innovative curriculum that engaged both the spiritual and social dimensions of ministry, inspiring calls for other seminaries to follow its example.

Top Ten Massachusetts Institutions with Strong Tenure Foothold (continued)

In continuation with the previous article, here are the next five institutions in Massachusetts with the strongest tenure foothold:

Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT)

MIT has one of the highest tenured faculty rates in the state, with over 90% of instructors being tenured. The university’s rigorous research and academic programs have attracted top scholars and researchers with a commitment to leadership in diverse fields, providing students with unique opportunities.

This commitment has also translated into increased job security for faculty members.

Roxbury Community College

Roxbury Community College has a tenure rate of 95%, demonstrating a strong commitment to supporting its faculty through job security and career development opportunities. The institution’s faculty is diverse and committed to providing academic opportunities for first-generation students and those from underrepresented backgrounds.

Cape Cod Community College

With an over 80% tenured faculty rate,

Cape Cod Community College is committed to providing job security and a high-quality educational experience for its students. The college offers a range of programming opportunities and partnerships that provide students with exceptional learning experiences and opportunities for growth.

Holyoke Community College

Holyoke Community College has a tenure rate of over 70%, attracting experienced and knowledgeable instructors who are committed to helping their students succeed. The faculty includes experts in their fields, providing top-quality instruction to students in a diverse range of programs.

Massachusetts College of Art and Design

Massachusetts College of Art and Design has a tenure rate of over 60%, ensuring that its faculty members are able to devote their time and energy to research and teaching opportunities. As an institution committed to the arts and design, the school’s diverse faculty offers students unique and experienced expertise that inspires intellectual and creative exploration.


Tenure is an important aspect of academic freedom and job security for faculty members in higher education institutions. It provides a foundation of support for research, teaching, scholarship, and service, benefiting both faculty members and students alike.

Through a close analysis of Massachusetts higher education institutions, it is clear that many institutions have made a strong commitment to supporting their faculty with job security and resources.

Extended List of Massachusetts Institutions with Tenure Percentages

In addition to the previously mentioned Massachusetts institutions, here is an extended list of institutions with varying levels of tenure percentages:

Institutions with High Tenure Percentages:

– Massachusetts College of Liberal Arts (MCLA): MCLA is a public liberal arts college with a tenure rate of over 70%. The college’s faculty members are dedicated to providing a high-quality liberal arts education with a focus on critical thinking and community engagement.

– Smith College: Smith College, a private women’s liberal arts college in Northampton, boasts a tenure rate of over 60%. The faculty at Smith College are leaders in their fields, ensuring a rigorous and impactful educational experience for students.

– Suffolk University: Suffolk University, located in downtown Boston, has a tenure rate of over 50%. The university’s faculty is committed to combining academic rigor with real-world experience to prepare students for successful careers in a variety of industries.

– Boston University: Boston University is a private research university with a tenure rate of over 40%. With a wide range of academic programs and a faculty known for their expertise, Boston University offers students a rich educational experience.

– Brandeis University: Brandeis University, a private research university in Waltham, has a tenure rate of over 40%. The faculty at Brandeis are known for their commitment to interdisciplinary research and teaching that promotes social justice and global understanding.

Institutions with Low or No Tenure Percentages:

– Curry College: Curry College is a private college in Milton with a low tenure rate. The focus at Curry College is primarily on teaching, with a faculty that includes both full-time and adjunct professors.

– Hult International Business School: Hult International Business School, with a campus in Cambridge, does not have a traditional tenure system. The school focuses on providing students with a global perspective and hands-on learning experiences in the field of business.

– Bay State College: Bay State College, a private career-focused college in Boston, does not have a tenure system. The college emphasizes practical skills and offers associate’s and bachelor’s degree programs that align with industry demands.

Wrapping Up and Further Reading

In exploring the landscape of tenure in Massachusetts institutions, it is evident that tenure percentages can vary widely. While many schools prioritize tenure as a means of supporting faculty and maintaining academic freedom, other institutions have chosen alternative paths to meet their specific educational goals.

For those interested in learning more about the topic of tenure and its impact, there are various resources available. The National Center for Education Statistics website and the Integrated Postsecondary Education Data System (IPEDS) database provide comprehensive data on institutions, including faculty tenure rates.

These resources offer a wealth of information for those who wish to delve deeper into the subject. Additionally, there are numerous articles and publications that explore the relationship between higher education and employment, as well as rankings of the best colleges for specific career paths.

These resources can assist students in making informed decisions about their educational journeys and provide insights into the ways in which tenure intersects with career prospects. As the landscape of higher education continues to evolve, discussions surrounding tenure and its role in institutional success will undoubtedly continue.

Whether supporting faculty members in their pursuit of knowledge or guiding students towards fulfilling academic experiences, tenure remains an essential component of the higher education system. In conclusion, the article has explored the importance and purpose of academic tenure, as well as the trends and impact of tenure in higher education institutions.

Tenure serves to defend academic freedom and protect faculty members who tackle controversial subjects. While there are criticisms of the tenure system, it remains crucial for maintaining the quality of education and the integrity of research.

Additionally, the article has highlighted specific Massachusetts institutions with strong tenure footholds. The variety of tenure percentages across institutions emphasizes the complex nature of the academic landscape.

By understanding the significance of tenure and its role in academia, students and faculty members can make informed decisions and contribute to the continued growth of higher education.

Popular Posts